Wild West Podcast
Welcome to the Wild West podcast, where fact and legend merge. We present the true accounts of individuals who settled in towns built out of hunger for money, regulated by fast guns, who walked on both sides of the law, patrolling, investing in, and regulating the brothels, saloons, and gambling houses. These are stories of the men who made the history of the Old West come alive - bringing with them the birth of legends, brought to order by a six-gun and laid to rest with their boots on. Join us as we take you back in history to the legends of the Wild West. You can support our show by subscribing to Exclusive access to premium content at Wild West Podcast + https://www.buzzsprout.com/64094/subscribe or just buy us a cup of coffee at https://buymeacoffee.com/wildwestpodcast
Wild West Podcast
Gunfights and Myths: The Truth About Billy Brooks
This episode is only available to subscribers.
Wild West Podcast +
Exclusive access to premium content!Get ready to saddle up and dive into the Wild West like never before! Introducing the dynamic duo, Sam Bass and Calamity Jane, your thrilling new hosts for the extended content of the Wild West Podcast. Adventure awaits as they bring the legendary tales of the frontier to life!
The frontier settlement of Dodge City earned its nickname "Bibulous Babylon" honestly in 1873. With no formal law enforcement and a population explosion of buffalo hunters and railroad workers, violence flourished—15 to 30 people died violently that first year alone. Boot Hill Cemetery filled quickly with those who "died with their boots on."
Enter Billy Brooks, a man whose reputation preceded him. Already known as "Bully Brooks," he'd been a buffalo hunter, stagecoach driver renowned for delivering mail through flooded creeks, and briefly served as Newton's city marshal where he'd been shot three times yet still chased his attackers for miles. When concerned Dodge City businessmen needed someone to impose order without official backing, Brooks seemed the perfect solution—a man whose mere presence might deter troublemakers.
Legend claims Brooks engaged in a staggering 15 gunfights during his brief tenure, reportedly killing seven or eight men. But when we examine the historical record closely, a different picture emerges. Most of these alleged confrontations lack names, dates, or any primary documentation. What we can verify are just two significant incidents: shooting railroad yardmaster Brownie through the head (who surprisingly survived) and more tellingly, backing down from Kirk Jordan in a public confrontation that shattered his fearsome image. After hiding under a bed until nightfall, Brooks left town, his effectiveness as a lawman permanently compromised.
His life spiraled downward from there—returning to stagecoach driving before losing his job, then turning to horse theft, which led to his arrest and eventual lynching by vigilantes in 1874. Brooks' story perfectly encapsulates the contradictions of frontier justice: hired to impose order through intimidation, he ultimately fell victim to the same extra-legal violence he represented.
What does our fascination with figures like Brooks reveal about our relationship with the American frontier? Why do we cling to the 15 gunfights legend despite limited evidence? Join us as we separate Wild West myth from documented reality, and consider what stories like his tell us about ourselves.
Ready to explore more frontier tales? Subscribe to our podcast and check out our illustrated dime novel publications through the link in our description.
"Edward Masterson and the Texas Cowboys," penned by Michael King, takes readers on an exhilarating ride through the American West, focusing on the lively and gritty cattle town of Dodge City, Kansas. This thrilling dime novel plunges into the action-packed year of Ed Masterson's life as a lawman, set against the backdrop of the chaotic cattle trade, filled with fierce conflicts, shifting loyalties, and rampant lawlessness. You can order the book on Amazon.
Dodge City 1873. Picture this A brand spanking new settlement, population just exploding, with buffalo hunters, railroad workers, you name it. Right, but law and order, let's just say it was kind of on back order.
Speaker 2:Definitely not established yet.
Speaker 1:Yeah, no official police force, no courts really running, not even a proper jail for the troublemakers, nothing. And in its first year alone estimates you know. They say maybe 15 to 30 people met violent ends 15 to 30?
Speaker 2:That's a lot.
Speaker 1:It is Earned that rather colorful nickname, beautiful Bibulus Babylon.
Speaker 2:And well, it contributed a lot to filling up boot hill early on boot hill yeah, the cemetery for those who died, you know, with their boots on a frontier tinderbox, really just waiting for a spark exactly, and that's exactly where our deep dive is taking us.
Speaker 1:Today we're really focusing on one person who walked right into that chaos, billy brooks. You shared this great collection of articles, historical, historical accounts and our mission here is to try and cut through the tall tales, get to the heart of his actual involvement in gunfights during that really explosive time in Dodge.
Speaker 2:It's a crucial thing to do, because history in places like that well, it often blurs the line between what really happened and you know the stories that get told later.
Speaker 1:So who was this guy stepping into this frontier powder keg, Billy Brooks? He arrives in Dodge City already carrying a reputation. That was well complex, I guess, and pretty intimidating.
Speaker 2:Okay, so he wasn't unknown.
Speaker 1:Not at all. Before Dodge, he'd been a buffalo hunter, even picked up the nickname Buffalo Bill.
Speaker 2:Oh, the Buffalo Bill.
Speaker 1:Well, no, not the Cody we usually think of. Seems like that nickname was kind of popular back then. If you guys had it.
Speaker 2:Confusing right.
Speaker 1:Yeah, that happens a lot on the frontier. Shared nicknames makes tracing people tricky.
Speaker 2:No kidding. So later he swaps buffalo hunting for stagecoaches. Drove routes first between Wichita and Fort Sill, then later up to Newton, which was another pretty ratty town.
Speaker 1:And the stories say he was known for his nerve like really pushing those coaches through flooded creeks just to get the mail delivered.
Speaker 2:Shows a certain grit, doesn't it? Dependability in a tough job.
Speaker 1:Totally, but it's his hard case image that really sets the scene for Dodge City. He was also known as Bully Brooks Bully Brooks, okay, and back in 1872, he was actually the city marshal in Newton for a bit.
Speaker 2:Ah, so he had some law enforcement experience.
Speaker 1:He did and get this. While he was marshal he apparently tangled with some Texas cowboys. He was trying to run out of town, ended up getting shot three times.
Speaker 2:Three times.
Speaker 1:Yeah, and he still chased them for about 10 miles.
Speaker 2:Wow, ok, that definitely paints a picture Tenacity and clearly willing to use violence.
Speaker 1:Absolutely. And the rumors even before he showed up in Dodge. They painted him as a guy who'd already been in several gunfights, maybe left a few men dead. So you see, this wasn't just some random guy showing up.
Speaker 2:No, he had a history.
Speaker 1:Exactly this pre-existing reputation for violence was like key to the role he ended up playing in Dodge City.
Speaker 2:Precisely In a place with no formal law, reputation was power. It worked for him and it worked for the people looking for some kind of you know, rough order.
Speaker 1:And that's just what happened. You had these concerned businessmen in Dodge.
Speaker 2:Right.
Speaker 1:Seeing all the chaos, probably worried about their investments.
Speaker 2:I don't understand.
Speaker 1:So, with no official police, they basically took matters into their own hands. They hired Billy Brooks, kind of a private, unofficial lawman. The sources call him different things, you know deputy assistant marshal, sometimes just lawman.
Speaker 2:It really shows you the kind of pragmatic, maybe even desperate steps people took. The thinking was you fight fire with fire. Right, you need someone tough, maybe even a bit dangerous, to control the dangerous elements.
Speaker 1:Okay, so now we get to the really juicy part, the legend. A lot of cats just throw this number out there 15 gunfights 15?. Yeah, 15 gunfights. Billy Brooks was supposedly in during his first month, or maybe first few months in Dodge City. Some even say like seven or eight people die in those fights 15 in a few months.
Speaker 2:That sounds well, almost unbelievable, like something from a dime novel.
Speaker 1:It really does.
Speaker 2:But you have to look closely at how these claims are stated in the records right.
Speaker 1:Exactly, and when you actually dig into the sources you shared, you keep seeing these little phrases.
Speaker 2:It is said reportedly Ah, the weasel words Hearsay.
Speaker 1:Totally hearsay, and what's really missing is any solid proof for that specific number. There are no dates, no names of opponents for most of these alleged fights, no locations.
Speaker 2:And no primary sources backing up that precise count.
Speaker 1:Right.
Speaker 2:Than the material we're looking at.
Speaker 1:Right that lack of specific detail for such a huge number of fights. It's pretty telling, isn't?
Speaker 2:it. It strongly suggests that number 15, it probably became part of the local legend. You know More folklore than hard fact.
Speaker 1:Yeah, I think so too. So what do we do with this 15 gunfights thing? It feels more symbolic, like a way to express just how dangerous people thought he was and how dangerous Dodge City was.
Speaker 2:That's a really good way to put it His violent reputation. Landing in that violent town, it was like fertile ground for these legends. Maybe the big number just helped cement Dodge's image as truly wild and Brooks is the kind of guy who could handle it, even if brutally.
Speaker 1:Makes sense. It speaks to how stories grow right. Yeah, Especially those exciting Wild West tales. Perceptions become reality in the telling.
Speaker 2:Absolutely yeah. So we have to conclude that while 15 gunfights makes a great story, we just can't accept it as a verifiable number based on the evidence we've got.
Speaker 1:Agreed. So let's move away from the legend and look at incidents that are actually documented, at least somewhat, in your sources. The legend, and look at incidents that are actually documented, at least somewhat, in your sources.
Speaker 2:Okay, let's do that.
Speaker 1:One involves Brooks shooting a man named Brownie Brownie right. Yeah, Brownie was the Santa Fe railroad yardmaster and Brooks, acting as assistant marshal, reportedly shot him through the head.
Speaker 2:Wow Through the head Very direct.
Speaker 1:Very, and the sources hint it might have been personal, maybe a dispute over a dance hall girl, someone called Captain Drew.
Speaker 2:The classic dance hall girl element Fits the stereotype, doesn't it?
Speaker 1:It really does. So after the shooting, brownie gets taken to the Dodge house and Captain Drew, the dance hall girl apparently she's the one who nurses him- Interesting twist. And here's the kicker Everyone thought the wound was fatal. I mean, one account says you could see brain matter.
Speaker 2:Grim detail.
Speaker 1:Super grim, but somehow Brownie pulls through. He actually recovered and was back at work a few months later. Just incredible.
Speaker 2:He actually recovered and was back at work a few months later. Just incredible, amazing resilience, or maybe good nursing, from Captain Drew. And the timing on that one. One source says winter of 1872.
Speaker 1:Yeah, which probably means early 1873, right when books would have been new in town. So it fits our time frame, okay. So the big question was this a gunfight? Well, the accounts we have, they don't actually say Brownie fired back, or even if he was armed.
Speaker 2:Right. One source just says Brooks gunned down Brownie.
Speaker 1:Exactly Gunned down. Sounds pretty one sided. So it was definitely a shooting by Brooks. But was it a reciprocal gunfight? We can't be sure from this information. That distinction is important, not every shooting is a two way fight and this incident probably didn't help Brooks' reputation among some folks. It likely fed those concerns about him being maybe too quick on the trigger, you know, and the questionable circumstances around some of his actions Makes sense.
Speaker 2:Okay, yeah.
Speaker 1:Described as a shooting scrape right on the street, and Jordan, apparently he was armed with a big, powerful buffalo gun. A serious weapon, definitely.
Speaker 2:And Jordan actually, apparently he was armed with a big, powerful buffalo gun, a serious weapon Definitely, and Jordan actually fired at Brooks. So shots were exchanged, or at least fired at Brooks.
Speaker 1:Yes, and Brooks' reaction. He apparently dove behind a water barrel.
Speaker 2:A water barrel.
Speaker 1:Yeah, the bullet went through it apparently, but lost its force. But here's the really crucial part Multiple sources say Brooks backed down.
Speaker 2:Backed down from Kirk Jordan.
Speaker 1:That's what they say. He reportedly hid one story even says, under a bed in a livery stable until dark.
Speaker 2:Hiding under a bed. That doesn't sound like the bully Brooks reputation.
Speaker 1:Not at all. And then, under cover of darkness, he was supposedly taken out of town to Fort Dodge for safety, and he didn't come back to Dodge City after that.
Speaker 2:Wow, okay, that sounds like a turning point. Yeah, and unlike Brownie, this one clearly qualifies as a gunfight right.
Speaker 1:I'd say so. Armed confrontation, jordan fires Brooks is the target taking cover.
Speaker 2:Yeah, but Brooks backing down then leaving town, that must have seriously damaged his standing. His whole authority was based on that fearsome image. What happens when someone calls your bluff?
Speaker 1:Oh, exactly, it suggests maybe his reputation was intimidating but not absolute. And having such a public well retreat in a town that valued toughness above all else, that would kill your credibility.
Speaker 2:Yeah, that probably explains why he left soon after Reputation once cracked like that on the frontier, it's hard to fix.
Speaker 1:OK, so beyond those two incidents, brownie and Jordan we get into those fuzzier, unsubstantiated claims.
Speaker 2:The legends again.
Speaker 1:Right Like that story that keeps popping up about Brooks killing four brothers.
Speaker 2:Oh yeah, the revenge story.
Speaker 1:Yeah, supposedly they were after him because he'd killed a fifth brother earlier. And the detail they always add is that he shot each of the four brothers four times.
Speaker 2:Four shots each. That sounds overly dramatic, almost too neat, like something out of a storybook, not real life.
Speaker 1:It has that feel, doesn't it? That symmetry Four brothers, four shots each Feels like folklore.
Speaker 2:Very much so yeah.
Speaker 1:Precise, dramatic details like that, especially with no backup, often signal embellishment over time. And then there's that other claim about him killing another man over a dance hall girl Another one. Hmm, yeah, and given the brownie incident, already involved, captain Drew. Well, you wonder, right, is this just a confused retelling of the brownie shooting?
Speaker 2:That's definitely possible. You wonder right, is this just a confused retelling of the brownie shooting? That's definitely possible. Or maybe it was another incident, but the details got lost and merged with the brownie story, as people told it over and over Legends tend to do that combine similar events.
Speaker 1:But again, when you look closely at these stories the four brothers, the second dance hall killing the sources you shared are missing, those key details.
Speaker 2:No names, no dates, no locations.
Speaker 1:Exactly, they feel like tall tales.
Speaker 2:Yeah.
Speaker 1:They definitely add to the legend of Bully Brooks, make him seem larger than life, but we can't really count them as documented gunfights based on what we have.
Speaker 2:Agreed. It's that classic pattern. A couple of specific incidents, maybe a bit murky, themselves surrounded by these much more dramatic but totally unproven stories. Surrounded by these much more dramatic but totally unproven stories. It really shows how hard it is to separate fact from myth with these frontier figures.
Speaker 1:So Brooks leaves Dodge City. The reasons seem pretty clear Growing unease about his methods being too quick, the brownie shooting.
Speaker 2:And definitely that public backing down from Kirk Jordan.
Speaker 1:Yeah, that seems like the final straw. He'd, as one source, nicely put it worn out his welcome.
Speaker 2:Not the light way of saying he was probably run out of town, or strongly encouraged to leave Pretty much.
Speaker 1:So after Dodge he actually goes back to driving stagecoach for a bit for the Southwestern Stage Company.
Speaker 2:Back to his old job.
Speaker 1:Yeah, but then early 1874, the company loses its mail contract Big blow, and Brooks is out of work its mail contract.
Speaker 2:Big blow and Brooks is out of work. Ah, so from feared lawman even if controversial to unemployed, that's a tough spot for a guy like him.
Speaker 1:And this is where things take a really dark turn. June 1874, Brooks is accused of getting involved in stealing mules and horses. Stealing them From who? From the rival stage company, the one that got the mail contract.
Speaker 2:Ah, okay, so the motive was maybe revenge or trying to sabotage them?
Speaker 1:Apparently. Yeah, sabotage the competition. Maybe hope Southwestern gets the contract back and he gets his job back. So he goes from hired gun to alleged horse thief.
Speaker 2:Wow, a desperate move, suggests he maybe couldn't really function outside that world of violence and easy solutions.
Speaker 1:It seems like it. And that path didn't last long either. July 1874, just a month later, Brooks and two buddies are arrested near Pauldwell, Kansas.
Speaker 2:Arrested for the horse theft.
Speaker 1:Yeah, related to stealing that stagecoach stock. They're put in jail to await trial.
Speaker 2:Okay, so the legal system might actually step in here.
Speaker 1:Oh, how about that? The trial never happened. Oh, why not Vigilantes Frontier justice? I guess you'd call it. Or why not Vigilantes Frontier justice?
Speaker 2:I guess you'd call it or maybe just mob rule Right. That happened a lot.
Speaker 1:Exactly July 29th 1874, a mob storms the jail where Brooks and his associates are held.
Speaker 2:Just stormed it.
Speaker 1:Yep Overpowered the jailers, dragged the three men out, took them to a tree right on the main road.
Speaker 2:Oh no.
Speaker 1:Yeah, and despite them pleading for mercy, apparently all three were hanged.
Speaker 2:Hanged by a mob.
Speaker 1:And there's a particularly nasty detail. The sources say the rope didn't break Brooks' neck properly. He actually died by strangulation.
Speaker 2:Ugh. A really brutal end Shows how volatile things were, even outside the wildest towns.
Speaker 1:And there's a real grim irony here, isn't there? He ends up killed by a vigilante mob, which is basically the same kind of extra legal violence that was happening all the time in Dodge City, when he was supposedly the law.
Speaker 2:That's a powerful point. The lines were just so blurred back then between lawman, gunman and mob justice.
Speaker 1:Absolutely. It feels like the very skills and the reputation that made him useful, or at least employable, in chaotic Dodge City. They just didn't translate well. They actually might have worked against him when things got slightly more settled.
Speaker 2:So let's wrap this up. We dove deep into Billy Brooks in Dodge City 1873. What are the main things we found?
Speaker 1:Well, I think the biggest takeaway is just how different the legend is from the documented reality. Based on the sources, we looked at those stories of 15 gunfights, tons of deaths they seem much more like folklore. What we could actually pin down was maybe one confirmed gunfight, the Kirk Jordan encounter, where Brooks backed down.
Speaker 2:And one confirmed shooting where Brooks was the shooter the Brownie incident but we're not sure if it was a two-way fight.
Speaker 1:That's a long way from the myth of the invincible gunfighter taking on all comers.
Speaker 2:It really highlights that challenge of studying the Old West. As a myth-making reputation, they often overshadow the actual facts. You really have to dig into the sources, look for evidence and be careful about distinguishing documented actions from those colorful legends.
Speaker 1:And thinking about Brooks's legacy in Dodge City. It's complicated, right, he was hired to stop the lawlessness, but his own violent methods probably just added to the town's wild and wicked reputation.
Speaker 2:He sort of embodies that contradiction, hired to bring order, but maybe bringing his own kind of chaos.
Speaker 1:Yeah, and his short time there ending with him being pressured out after the Jordan fight. It kind of shows the limits of just hiring the toughest guy around without any real rules or oversight.
Speaker 2:It really does. He becomes this symbol of the volatile nature of early frontier law enforcement, necessary maybe in some eyes, but also deeply problematic. His story really is a window into the difficulties of establishing real law and order through, well, essentially, hiring gunslingers.
Speaker 1:So here's a final thought, maybe for you, the listener, to chew on Think about how that intense, rough environment of a place like Dodge City didn't just shape what people did guys like Billy Brooks but also how it fueled the stories we tell about them. What does it tell us that the 15 gunfights legend is still so persistent, even without solid proof? What does that say about our own fascination with the Wild West, with these larger-than-life figures, even when the historical details might be a bit more well ordinary or at least less dramatic?
Speaker 3:At the Wild West podcast, we are on an inspiring mission to revive the spirit of the classic dime novel, reimagining it for a modern audience while accounting for inflation in both price and narrative depth. Our goal is to invigorate these captivating stories, ensuring that they not only echo the charm of their predecessors but also resonate with contemporary themes and characters. Predecessors, but also resonate with contemporary themes and characters. In doing so, we create a literary experience that honors the rich tradition of storytelling, allowing these tales to thrive and evolve, captivating readers for generations to come. If you are interested in purchasing one or more of these fully illustrated dime novel publications, you can click on the link provided on the description page of this podcast.
